Governance and Stewardship
This document defines how the Declaration of Private Generative Rights is stewarded, revised, and preserved over time.
The purpose of governance is not control, enforcement, or authority. It is continuity, integrity, and ethical clarity.
1. Stewardship, not ownership
The Declaration of Private Generative Rights is not owned.
It is stewarded to preserve:
- Textual integrity
- Ethical continuity
- Public trust
- Historical traceability
Stewardship does not grant the power to enforce, certify, or compel adoption. It grants only the responsibility to protect meaning.
2. Scope of governance
Governance applies only to:
- The canonical text (
DECLARATION.md) - Official versioning
- Public change records
- Adoption language consistency
Governance does not apply to:
- How others interpret the declaration
- Whether organizations adopt or reject it
- Legal enforcement or compliance
- Private derivative frameworks (when clearly labeled)
3. Versioning principles
The declaration uses semantic versioning, interpreted ethically:
Patch versions (v1.0.x)
Clarifications, typographical corrections, formatting changes
No change in meaning or scopeMinor versions (v1.x.0)
Additive clarifications, new articles, or expanded commentary
Must not contradict prior principlesMajor versions (v2.0.0)
Ethical re-foundation
Reserved for rare, explicit, and publicly documented shifts
No version may retroactively invalidate prior adoptions.
Adoption is bound to the version in effect at the time of adoption.
4. Change proposals
Any proposed change to the canonical text must include:
- A clear description of the proposed change
- A rationale explaining why the change is necessary
- An explicit statement of whether the change is:
- Clarifying
- Additive
- Foundational
Proposals must be publicly visible before adoption.
5. Cooling-off period
To prevent reactive or political drift:
- All non-trivial changes require a public cooling-off period
- The minimum cooling-off period is 30 days
- During this time, feedback may be received and documented
Urgency is not sufficient justification for bypassing this process.
6. Emergency clarifications
Emergency updates are permitted only to correct:
- Factual errors
- Broken references
- Ambiguities that materially misrepresent intent
Emergency updates may not:
- Introduce new principles
- Remove protections
- Narrow ethical scope
All emergency changes must be logged explicitly.
7. Transparency and changelog
Every modification to the declaration must be recorded in CHANGELOG.md, including:
- Version number
- Date
- Nature of change
- Summary of impact
No change may be silent. No change may be backdated.
8. Divergent versions
Derivative or modified versions of the declaration are permitted.
However:
- They must be clearly labeled as divergent
- They may not use the original title without qualification
- They may not imply endorsement or stewardship authority
Divergence is ethical. Silent mutation is not.
9. Stewardship continuity
If stewardship must pass to new maintainers:
- The transition must be publicly documented
- No change in ethical scope may occur during transition
- Historical versions must remain permanently accessible
Stewardship exists to preserve trust across time, not to concentrate power.
10. Final principle
This declaration is governed to resist erosion, not to accelerate change.
Ethics gains authority through consistency, not speed. Legitimacy arises from restraint, not control.
Governance is not the power to decide what is right.
It is the discipline to prevent meaning from being quietly rewritten.
Governance and Stewardship
This document defines how the Declaration of Private Generative Rights is stewarded, revised, and preserved over time.
The purpose of governance is not control, enforcement, or authority. It is continuity, integrity, and ethical clarity.
1. Stewardship, not ownership
The Declaration of Private Generative Rights is not owned.
It is stewarded to preserve:
- Textual integrity
- Ethical continuity
- Public trust
- Historical traceability
Stewardship does not grant the power to enforce, certify, or compel adoption. It grants only the responsibility to protect meaning.
2. Scope of governance
Governance applies only to:
- The canonical text (
DECLARATION.md) - Official versioning
- Public change records
- Adoption language consistency
Governance does not apply to:
- How others interpret the declaration
- Whether organizations adopt or reject it
- Legal enforcement or compliance
- Private derivative frameworks (when clearly labeled)
3. Versioning principles
The declaration uses semantic versioning, interpreted ethically:
Patch versions (v1.0.x)
Clarifications, typographical corrections, formatting changes
No change in meaning or scopeMinor versions (v1.x.0)
Additive clarifications, new articles, or expanded commentary
Must not contradict prior principlesMajor versions (v2.0.0)
Ethical re-foundation
Reserved for rare, explicit, and publicly documented shifts
No version may retroactively invalidate prior adoptions.
Adoption is bound to the version in effect at the time of adoption.
4. Change proposals
Any proposed change to the canonical text must include:
- A clear description of the proposed change
- A rationale explaining why the change is necessary
- An explicit statement of whether the change is:
- Clarifying
- Additive
- Foundational
Proposals must be publicly visible before adoption.
5. Cooling-off period
To prevent reactive or political drift:
- All non-trivial changes require a public cooling-off period
- The minimum cooling-off period is 30 days
- During this time, feedback may be received and documented
Urgency is not sufficient justification for bypassing this process.
6. Emergency clarifications
Emergency updates are permitted only to correct:
- Factual errors
- Broken references
- Ambiguities that materially misrepresent intent
Emergency updates may not:
- Introduce new principles
- Remove protections
- Narrow ethical scope
All emergency changes must be logged explicitly.
7. Transparency and changelog
Every modification to the declaration must be recorded in CHANGELOG.md, including:
- Version number
- Date
- Nature of change
- Summary of impact
No change may be silent. No change may be backdated.
8. Divergent versions
Derivative or modified versions of the declaration are permitted.
However:
- They must be clearly labeled as divergent
- They may not use the original title without qualification
- They may not imply endorsement or stewardship authority
Divergence is ethical. Silent mutation is not.
9. Stewardship continuity
If stewardship must pass to new maintainers:
- The transition must be publicly documented
- No change in ethical scope may occur during transition
- Historical versions must remain permanently accessible
Stewardship exists to preserve trust across time, not to concentrate power.
10. Final principle
This declaration is governed to resist erosion, not to accelerate change.
Ethics gains authority through consistency, not speed. Legitimacy arises from restraint, not control.
Governance is not the power to decide what is right.
It is the discipline to prevent meaning from being quietly rewritten.